Root Canal vs. Tooth Extraction: Choosing the Best Option

Dr. Lee locking arms with Dr. Ngai in the waiting room of Newbury Dental
Scroll down to next section

Root Canal vs. Tooth Extraction: Choosing the Best Option

When it comes to dental health, making informed decisions is paramount. Our teeth play a crucial role not only in our physical health but also in our overall confidence and well-being. Two standard procedures often present a difficult choice for patients: root canal treatments and tooth extractions. Both have advantages and drawbacks; understanding these is key to choosing which best suits your oral health needs. This blog post aims to comprehensively compare these two treatments, outlining their processes, recovery times, costs, and potential impacts on your health. With this information, we hope to empower you to make well-informed decisions about your oral health.

What is a Root Canal?

A root canal, clinically referred to as endodontic therapy, is a dental procedure aimed at salvaging a severely injured, cracked, or decayed tooth when its pulp (the soft inner part of the tooth containing blood vessels and nerves) becomes inflamed or infected. The procedure involves several steps. First, the dentist or endodontist (specializing in treating the inside of the tooth) removes the inflamed or infected pulp. After this, they carefully clean and disinfect the inside of the tooth, then fill and seal it with a rubber-like material called gutta-percha. Finally, the tooth is restored with a crown for protection and to ensure it functions like any other tooth.

Common reasons for needing a root canal include severe tooth decay, repeated dental procedures on the same tooth, or a crack or chip in the tooth. In some cases, an injury to a tooth may cause pulp damage, even if the tooth has no visible chips or cracks. If left untreated, such issues can lead to severe tooth pain or abscesses.

What is Tooth Extraction?

Tooth extraction, as the name suggests, is a dental procedure that involves removing a tooth from its socket in the bone. This procedure generally becomes necessary when a tooth has been damaged beyond repair by tooth decay or trauma.

The extraction process begins with applying a local anesthetic to numb the area where the tooth will be removed. For simple extraction, the dentist will loosen the tooth with an elevator tool and then extract the tooth using forceps. In the case of a surgical extraction, where the tooth may be broken off at the gum line or has not come into the mouth yet (as with some wisdom teeth), the dentist makes a small incision into your gum to surgically remove the broken tooth or impacted wisdom tooth.

Typically, tooth extraction might be the best option when a tooth is so damaged or decayed that repair is impossible. It could also be recommended to deal with overcrowded teeth or to prevent complications from 'wisdom teeth,' the last molars to come in. In addition, people receiving braces may need teeth extracted to create room for the teeth being moved into place. Tooth extraction can vastly improve oral health in these scenarios by preventing the spread of tooth decay and infection and by improving the alignment of the remaining teeth.

Comparative Analysis

Procedure Complexity

Root canal treatments and tooth extractions require professional expertise but differ in complexity. A root canal involves several steps—removing inflamed or infected pulp, cleaning and disinfection, filling and sealing, and restoring with a crown. On the other hand, straightforward tooth extractions are less complex as they typically only involve loosening and pulling the problematic tooth. However, surgical extraction might involve a slightly more complicated procedure if the tooth is broken off at the gum line or has not yet erupted.

Pain and Discomfort

While both procedures might sound daunting, modern dentistry ensures they are done with minimal discomfort. Local anesthesia makes both root canals and tooth extractions virtually painless. Post-procedure, patients may experience some discomfort, swelling, or mild pain; however, these are temporary and managed with over-the-counter painkillers. Tooth extraction might cause slightly more discomfort, creating a physical void where the tooth once was.

Recovery Time

Recovery times vary. A root canal recovery is generally quick, often requiring only a few days, as discomfort subsides once the infected pulp is removed and the tooth is sealed. Tooth extraction requires a more extended recovery period, typically one to two weeks, as the body needs time to heal the socket where the tooth was removed. Post-procedure care differs, too. A root canal doesn’t generally disrupt daily activities, but after a tooth extraction, certain activities such as strenuous exercise and smoking should be avoided to encourage healing and prevent complications.

Long-term Oral Health Implications

In terms of long-term oral health, a root canal can preserve the natural tooth and maintain the jawbone structure. Tooth extraction, while solving immediate issues, may lead to complications like shifting of the surrounding teeth, misalignment, and potential bone loss around the extraction site over time. However, these issues can be mitigated with replacements like bridges or implants.

Cost Comparison

Costs for both procedures can vary widely based on complexity, geography, and whether or not you have dental insurance. Generally, root canals can be more expensive upfront due to the procedure's complexity and the need for a crown afterwards. Tooth extractions are usually less costly initially, but bear in mind the potential costs of tooth replacement options if you choose to pursue them. Discussing these factors with your dentist and considering the immediate and long-term financial implications when making your decision is crucial.

Pros and Cons of Root Canal and Tooth Extraction

Root Canal


  • Preservation of Natural Tooth: The most significant advantage of a root canal is that it allows you to keep your natural tooth, maintaining its function and appearance.
  • Prevention of Spread: By removing the infected pulp, root canals prevent the spread of infection, reducing the risk of further dental problems.
  • Relatively Quick Recovery: The recovery period for a root canal is typically short, meaning minimal disruption to your daily activities.

Potential Drawbacks

  • Complex Procedure: Root canals can be more complex than extractions, potentially leading to longer treatment times and increased discomfort.
  • Cost: Root canals are generally more expensive than extractions, especially considering the additional cost of a crown to restore the tooth.

Tooth Extraction


  • Solves Immediate Issues: Tooth extraction provides an immediate solution to severely damaged or decayed teeth, alleviating pain and discomfort.
  • Simple Procedure: In many cases, extractions are simpler and more straightforward than root canals.
  • Cost-Effective: Extractions are typically less expensive upfront compared to root canals.

Potential Negatives

  • Longer Healing Time: The healing process after tooth extraction can take several weeks, longer than a root canal.
  • Potential for Future Dental Issues: Removal of a tooth can lead to shifting of other teeth, potentially causing misalignment. There may also be potential for bone loss at the extraction site.
  • Aesthetic Concerns: There's a visual impact when a tooth is removed, which may necessitate further cosmetic dentistry procedures.

Both root canal and tooth extraction have their merits and potential downsides. The best choice between the two will depend on various factors, including the condition of the tooth, cost considerations, and personal preference. Always consult your dentist or endodontist to understand the best approach for your situation.

Patient Considerations in Choosing Between Root Canal and Tooth Extraction

Patients should consider several factors when choosing between a root canal and tooth extraction.

Age and Overall Health

Age and overall health play a significant role in the decision-making process. Younger patients may be more able to heal and recover from procedures, making both options equally viable. The recovery process may be slower for older patients or those with compromised immune systems, particularly for extractions.

Specific Dental Conditions

The specific dental condition at hand is another critical consideration. For instance, a root canal could be suitable if tooth decay is early. However, extraction may be best if the tooth is severely decayed or damaged.

Personal Comfort and Anxiety Levels

Personal comfort and anxiety levels should also be considered. Some patients may feel more anxious about a complex root canal procedure and prefer the simplicity of an extraction, while others might fear the void left by an extracted tooth.

Financial Considerations

Financial considerations also come into play. While root canals might be more expensive upfront, they could save you money in the long run by preventing further dental issues. In contrast, extractions are typically less costly initially, but the costs of subsequent teeth replacement options should be factored in.

The Importance of Professional Consultation

Regardless of your initial inclinations, it is crucial to consult with a dental professional before deciding. Dentists and endodontists can evaluate your specific situation, explain the potential risks and benefits of both procedures and help you make an informed decision about the best route for your long-term oral health. Remember, every patient's situation is unique, and what works for one person might not work for another. Always seek professional advice to ensure the best outcome for your oral health.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: How painful is a root canal procedure?

A: With modern anesthetics and techniques, patients often experience little to no pain during a root canal procedure. There may be some discomfort or minor pain in the days following the process, but this can usually be managed with over-the-counter pain relievers.

Q: How long does a root canal procedure take?

A: The length of the procedure can vary depending on the severity of the infection and the complexity of the root system, but most root canals can be completed in one or two appointments, each lasting about 90 minutes or up to three hours in a single session.

Q: What happens after a tooth extraction?

A: After a tooth extraction, it's normal to experience some swelling and mild discomfort. Your dentist will provide specific aftercare instructions to ensure a smooth recovery. This typically includes rest, avoiding certain foods and activities, and cleaning the extraction site.

Q: How long does it take to recover from a tooth extraction?

A: Recovery times can vary greatly depending on the complexity of the extraction, but most people can expect to recover fully within one to two weeks.

Q: Which is better: root canal or tooth extraction?

A: Both procedures have pros and cons, and the best choice will depend on various factors, including the condition of the tooth, your overall health, and your personal preferences. Always consult your dentist to discuss your options and make an informed decision.


Navigating the decision between a root canal and tooth extraction can be complex, with various factors. Both procedures have their advantages and potential downsides. Root canals can preserve the natural tooth and prevent further dental issues, but they can be more complex and costly. On the other hand, extractions provide immediate relief from severe tooth decay or damage and are often less expensive. Still, they may lead to future dental issues and require longer healing times.

The decision is inevitably influenced by individual factors such as age, overall health, specific dental conditions, personal comfort and anxiety levels, and financial circumstances. Therefore, consulting with a professional dentist or endodontist is paramount to evaluate your unique situation and guide you through the best option for your long-term oral health.

Remember, every patient's situation is different, and the most suitable course of action for one person might not be the same for another. Always seek professional advice, fully understand the implications of each procedure, and choose the path that ensures the best outcome for your oral health.

At Newbury Dental in South Edmonton, we're here to guide you through every step of your dental journey. We invite you to schedule a consultation with us so our professionals can evaluate your situation, alleviate your concerns, and help you make the right decision for your oral health. For more information or to book your consultation, visit our contact page.

Related Articles

Moss Wall in Newbury Dental, located in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Contact us

We look forward to meeting you! Call 780-760-3033, email, or request an appointment online to set up your first visit. We’ll be in touch soon!